Should The Phillies Let Brandon Marsh Face Left-Handers?
Dave Dombrowski has assembled an impressive roster that’s rolled through the competition on their way to the best record in baseball at the All-Star Break.
However, the Philadelphia Phillies have questions to answer during the second half of the regular season and as immediately as the MLB Trade Deadline on July 30th.
One important nugget of information will shape their roster construction and Rob Thomson’s managerial decisions.
The Phillies don’t have confidence in Brandon Marsh to produce offensively against left-handed pitchers.
Brandon Marsh By The Numbers
The Phillies have distributed Marsh’s opportunities unevenly since they acquired him from the Los Angeles Angels in July 2022 shortly after Thomson managed his first major league game.
He’s faced right-handers in 684 regular-season plate appearances in red pinstripes. He’s only made 187 plate appearances against lefties, accounting for about 22% of his chances.
Virtually all left-handed MLB hitters face left-handed pitchers less commonly because of the league’s surplus of righties and the natural platoon advantage. However, the drastic split indicates a lack of confidence in Marsh in an everyday role.
Thomson platooned Matt Vierling with Marsh in center field during the 2022 postseason. The Phillies skipper even began the 2023 postseason using Cristian Pache in a left field platoon. Marsh made only seven plate appearances against lefties in each of the two playoff runs.
Why doesn’t he get more opportunities? He simply hasn’t taken advantage of the chances he’s gotten to inspire the confidence of his manager or the front office.
| Batting Average vs. RHP | Batting Average vs. LHP | At-Bats vs. RHP | At-Bats vs. LHP | OPS vs. RHP | OPS vs. LHP | Home Runs vs. RHP | Home Runs vs. LHP | |
| With Los Angeles Angels (July 2021-July 2022) | .243 | .227 | 378 | 150 | .691 | .537 | 8 | 2 |
| 2022 (with Phillies) | .312 | .174 | 109 | 23 | .853 | .391 | 3 | 0 |
| 2023 | .292 | .229 | 308 | 96 | .864 | .717 | 9 | 3 |
| 2024 | .297 | .146 | 185 | 48 | .896 | .385 | 9 | 0 |
| Postseason | .254 | .286 | 63 | 14 | .808 | .786 | 3 | 0 |
Marsh brings a great glove to the outfield. His 11 defensive runs saved in left field account for more than double any other player on the Phillies roster in 2024.
His presence in the clubhouse has played a major part in establishing the atmosphere that’s made the current group of Phillies an incredible hit within the fan base.
However, the Phillies can’t overlook the glaring weakness in his offensive game.
They might choose to accept underwhelming offense from Johan Rojas in center field with a more defensive mindset. If the 23-year-old starts during the postseason, a World Series contender can’t afford another outfielder like Marsh with limited offensive expectations in certain matchups.
Phillies Outfield, Trade Deadline Plans
Tom McCarthy spoke on 97.5 The Fanatic about how the Phillies lineup will take shape down the stretch in 2024. Bob Cooney wants Thomson to commit to an everyday lineup with no platoons, but McCarthy pointed out Marsh’s key weakness.
“He’s close to being an everyday player offensively, but they just are not sold on his ability to hit left-handers.” –Tom McCarthy on 97.5 The Fanatic
The Phillies play-by-play broadcaster estimated a 90% chance that the Phillies don’t feel confidence in Marsh’s ability to fix his Achilles heel by October.
If fans need confirmation of that outlook, look at recent roster decisions. The Phillies ate serious money by releasing Whit Merrifield. They signed the veteran expecting that his ability to platoon in the outfield would be a major contribution.
They’re determined to give Weston Wilson a chance to play the role they wanted for Merrifield. They’d rather give a 29-year-old who had only 20 MLB at-bats before his promotion on July 12 a chance against left-handed starters for 18 days rather than give Brandon Marsh a short-term chance to improve his weakness.
If Wilson doesn’t impress drastically and immediately, Dombrowski will almost certainly look for a right-handed platoon option as his primary need ahead of the MLB Trade Deadline.
Lane Thomas, Taylor Ward, and Kevin Pillar would make sense as more affordable options than acquiring Luis Robert Jr. as a full-time center fielder.
Will Brandon Marsh Face Left-Handed Pitchers?
The Phillies don’t know what the playoffs hold. The Los Angeles Dodgers have leaned on primarily right-handed starters at the top of their rotation. Future Hall of Fame lefty Clayton Kershaw will make his push to regain form in the second half of the season, however.
A series against the Atlanta Braves would almost certainly mean facing left-handed pitchers Chris Sale and Max Fried.
Related Content: MLB Trade Deadline: 11 Options For The Philadelphia Phillies
The scrutiny to predict playoff matchups that are far from guaranteed seems like a stretch at first glance. Playoff games also provide opportunities for late-inning defensive replacements and pinch hit chances with favorable matchups. Marsh could be valuable in either spot if he doesn’t start against lefties.
However, consider that Dombrowski and the Phillies will pinpoint the smallest details in a season focused solely on the goal of winning the World Series.
Brandon Marsh is a talented major league outfielder with a great bat against right-handed pitchers, but the left-handed opponents have gotten the best of him too consistently.
Expect to see him platoon with another outfielder when the games matter most for the Phillies.
97.5 The Fanatic provides weekly news, analysis, and interviews about the 2024 Philadelphia Phillies season.
MLB Trade Deadline: 13 Options For The Philadelphia Phillies
Ryan Pressly
Ryan Pressly stood on the mound and watched Kyle Tucker squeeze a weak pop-up off the bat of Nick Castellanos in foul territory. Phillies fans watched helplessly as the Houston Astros clinched the 2022 World Series and ended one of the most memorable runs in Philadelphia sports history.
Could they cheer Pressly just two years later at Citizens Bank Park?
The 35-year-old former All-Star saved 90 games from 2021-23. He posted a WHIP under one and a modest 2.94 ERA during the three-year span. However, the Astros signed Josh Hader to push their long-time closer into a set-up role.
The Astros got off to a slow start in 2024. Although they still have a chance to climb back to the top of a wide-open AL West, they also have some incentive to sell veterans like Pressly, Justin Verlander, or Alex Bregman.
The Phillies have been confident in the closer by committee approach with Jose Alvarado and Jeff Hoffman at the back end. However, would they push both into set-up roles to land a full-time closer?
“I think it would depend on who’s out there. If there’s a guy out there who they think, ‘Hey, this guy is a closer with a capital C and we think he can help our team and we think we have the pieces to go get him,’ I don’t think that would stop them. It’s not like they’re not going to go after a guy because… (they) don’t want to give the ninth inning to one specific guy. I think they would.” -Matt Gelb on Philly Sports Tonight
FULL TRADE PROFILE: Ryan Pressly
Photo by Harry How/Getty Images
Ryan Helsley
The St. Louis Cardinals have dipped from the peak of their franchise height. The conversation at the beginning of the 2024 season shifted to the possibility of the Red Birds selling veteran players.
Ryan Helsley looked like a prime trade candidate after injuries had disrupted his rhythm as one of the best closers in the game.
The sixth-year reliever saved 28 games in 28 opportunities during the first half of the season. The Cardinals have stayed in the NL Central race, and they’re in even better position to earn an NL Wild Card berth.
Helsley looked like a good fit for the Phillies closer to the beginning of the season. However, Seranthony Dominguez might fill the need for a right-handed bullpen option internally.
The Cardinals also don’t look like they’re planning on selling. Helsley is slipping off Dave Dombrowski’s list.
Photo by Scott Kane/Getty Images
Zach Eflin
Why not bring back an old friend?
The Phillies traded Jimmy Rollins for Zach Eflin in 2014. The right-hander pitched seven seasons in red pinstripes. He filled a role at the back end of the rotation early in his career and slid toward the front in the final seasons of his tenure.
Eflin also pitched valuable relief innings during the run to the World Series in 2022.
The 30-year-old finished sixth in AL Cy Young voting in 2023. He posted a 4.20 ERA in the first half of 2024.
Destiny Lugardo made a compelling case for Eflin, even if a move doesn’t seem likely.
The MLB Trade Deadline market won’t include too many sellers. The Tampa Bay Rays could be one of them. The Phillies need immediate starting pitching depth with injuries to Taijuan Walker and Spencer Turnbull and right-handed relief options.
Crazier things than a reunion with Zach Eflin have happened.
Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images
Mason Miller
Bob Nightengale of USA Today floated the idea in May of the Oakland Athletics trading their star closer Mason Miller. However, he acknowledged the challenges that most teams would have putting together an adequate trade package.
The Phillies will wrestle with their willingness to trade top prospects. If they decide to move Andrew Painter, Justin Crawford, or Aidan Miller, they’re more likely to pursue an outfielder like Luis Robert Jr. to fill their biggest need.
If the Phillies decide to pursue bullpen help, Dombrowski will probably look for a cheaper option.
Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images
Michael Kopech
The Chicago White Sox might be the most obvious seller approaching July 30. They’ll probably look to move any and all veterans that can bring a return to reshape their latest rebuild.
The Phillies could look for bullpen help, and Michael Kopech looks like he’ll be available.
The 6-foot-4 reliever pitched in Chicago’s starting rotation in 2022 and 2023. He made 33 relief appearances during the first half of the 2024 season. He saved six games and blew four more opportunities on his way to a 4.59 ERA.
Seranthony Dominguez struggled out of the gates in 2024. However, he actually reached the midway point of the season with a better ERA than Kopech.
All contenders should look to add bullpen depth heading into October. Dombrowski could look to land Kopech for a small price. However, he won’t solve any major needs for the Phillies.
Photo by Nuccio DiNuzzo/Getty Images
Luis Robert Jr.
When Luis Robert Jr. is healthy, he’s one of the best center fielders in the majors.
Robert won a Gold Glove after a pandemic-shortened rookie season in 2020. He broke out offensively during the 2021 season with a .338 batting average and a .946 OPS (MLB Average: .728) in 68 games. He missed over three months with a hip injury, however.
The Cuban outfielder also inspired some confidence for the lowly White Sox with an excellent season in 2023. He hit 38 home runs in a career high 145 games, which landed him 12th in AL MVP voting.
FanGraphs ranked him the best fielder on the White Sox from 2021-2023 with 14 defensive runs saved (DRS). Johan Rojas is the only Phillies position player who recorded more during that span (in significantly fewer innings.)
Robert has also averaged over 20 stolen bases per 162 game pace during his MLB career.
The 26-year-old played only 311 of 486 regular-season games (roughly 64%) from 2021-2023. He played only seven games in 2024 before a hip injury sent him to the IL for two months.
An underwhelming on-base percentage and batting average last season might also cause concerns with a player who will command big money and a considerable trade package.
The White Sox will look for a package comparable to the Juan Soto deal if they trade Robert. They won’t get it for a player with his injury concerns, but the question is whether that price comes down enough to allow Dave Dombrowski land the crown jewel of the market.
Expect the Phillies to come up in all rumors surrounding Robert before July 30. The debates will include plenty of intrigue about the value of top prospects Andrew Painter, Justin Crawford, or Aidan Miller in a potential deal.
FULL TRADE PROFILE: Luis Robert Jr.
Photo by Quinn Harris/Getty Images
Brent Rooker
Brent Rooker caused a stir with a stunning performance at Citizens Bank Park from July 12-14 in a series victory for the A’s. He slugged three home runs during a 7-12 stretch with seven RBI. His two home runs in the Sunday finale traveled over 450 feet apiece into Ashburn Alley.
It was quite a showcase for an available player on a last-place team, but can the Phillies bring the blossoming right-handed slugger to Philadelphia?
The 29-year-old struggled to meet his draft pedigree before joining his fourth MLB team in 2023. Rooker finally broke out for the Athletics with 30 home runs and an .817 OPS in 137 games.
He’s followed it up with an even better pace in 2024. Rooker reached the All-Star Break with 22 home runs, 62 RBI, and a .291/.369/.573 slash line. He ranked eighth in OPS among qualified MLB hitters at .942.
Rooker has played exclusively as a designated hitter since May 30. He played 58 games in the outfield and spent 79 as a DH in 2023. He had a -2 rating in the FanGraphs Defensive Runs Saved metric in both right and left field last season. He followed it up with another -2 rating in fewer games in left this season.
He’d also command a substantial trade package. The Athletics would likely ask the Phillies to give up Miller, Painter, or Crawford.
Brent Rooker showcased an alluring prize at Citizens Bank Park, but a blockbuster trade would come with plenty of question marks for Dave Dombrowski.
FULL TRADE PROFILE: Brent Rooker
Photo by Hunter Martin/Getty Images
Lane Thomas
The Washington Nationals signed Lane Thomas to a one-year contract worth $5.45 million to play somewhat of a stopgap role with top prospects Dylan Crews and James Wood waiting in the wings.
The right-handed outfielder has slashed .256/.315/.444 in parts of four seasons since Washington acquired him at the MLB Trade Deadline in 2021. He shattered his career high with 28 home runs in 2023, helped out by a career high in plate appearances.
Thomas’ numbers dipped to .243/.302/.431 in 51 games during the first half of 2024. However, his hard hit rate has increased while his average exit velocity remained steady, indicating the likelihood that his numbers will progress back toward his career norms through the rest of the season.
Thomas also brings good speed on the basepaths. He stole 20 bags in 2023, and he’s on pace to surpass that career best in 2024.
His arm strength from the outfield is one of his best tools. He ranked second in the majors with 18 outfield assists in 2023, and he’s tied for fourth this season.
The sixth-year MLB veteran has played right field most commonly, but he’s shuffled to center and left at different points during his career. He will turn 29 in August.
The Nationals don’t have to sell before the MLB Trade Deadline. They held their own during the first half of the season to stay in the mix in a crowded group of middling NL teams. The new playoff structure keeps teams like the Nats in contention later into the season.
However, Lane Thomas makes sense if Dombrowski shops below the market for Luis Robert Jr. to find a platoon starter who allows Rob Thomson to sit Marsh against left-handed pitchers in the playoffs.
The Phillies would likely use Thomas mostly in left field, however. He played 73 games in left in 2022, but the Nationals have used him as a full-time right fielder the past two seasons. Dombrowski might have to limit one of his trade target’s skills because of the fit in the Phillies lineup.
FULL TRADE PROFILE: Lane Thomas
Photo by Matthew Stockman/Getty Images
Kyle Tucker
The Astros built a powerhouse with high draft picks that developed into big league stars. Their core has led them to seven consecutive ALCS appearances and World Series titles in 2017 and 2022.
Tucker joined the loaded group of sluggers with a breakout effort in the pandemic-shortened 2020 season. He’s followed it up with impressive home run totals of 30, 30, and 29 in the past three seasons, respectively.
Tucker is the most attractive of the outfielders named in trade rumors. He’ll also be the most difficult for a contending team to land ahead of the MLB Trade Deadline.
Phillies fans remember him most for his part in ending their miracle ride to the World Series in 2022. He slugged two home runs in the Fall Classic and squeezed a foul ball off the bat of Nick Castellanos for the final out of the Game 6 clincher.
The 27-year-old has hit a new level in a contract season in 2024. He ranked ninth in the majors in home runs, fourth in SLG%, and sixth in OPS through June 9.
After Tucker finished tied for 18th among all major leaguers in WAR in 2023, the stellar power numbers resulted in a surge up the Baseball Reference leaderboard into the top tier of MLB superstars.
Tucker will only earn $12 million in 2024, a salary that doesn’t accommodate his production, and he’s set to enter unrestricted free agency after the season.
Five things that need to fall into place for Dombrowski to execute the hypothetical trade.
- The Astros must be willing to sell their best hitter this season because of their underwhelming start.
- The Phillies must be willing to trade top prospects they ideally don’t want to part with.
- The Phillies must have a plan to re-sign Tucker at a number he sees fit on a team that he sees fit.
- Tucker must move back to left field after executing a successful transition to right the past three seasons.
- Dombrowski must outbid the Dodgers in search of an outfield bat.
The Phillies won’t leave any stones unturned on the trade market, and it never hurts to dream. However, a trade sending Kyle Tucker to the Phillies at the MLB Trade Deadline seems unlikely.
FULL TRADE PROFILE: Kyle Tucker
Photo by Carmen Mandatory/Getty Images
Randy Arozarena
A trade for Randy Arozarena would’ve looked somewhat like a blockbuster to Phillies fans before the 2024 season began.
He ruined any excitement with a brutal two-month stretch to begin the season. However, the 2021 Rookie of the Year hit above his career averages in a refreshing month of June.
Jeff Passan named Arozarena as a potential target for teams looking to add an outfield bat. Could the Phillies strike? The Rays might be one of the only sellers on the market by July 30.
Arozarena remains in play for Dave Dombrowski despite the slow start.
FULL TRADE PROFILE: Randy Arozarena
Photo by Mike Carlson/Getty Images
Jazz Chisholm
When rumors started to spread about Jazz Chisholm, Phillies fans started to listen intently. The former top prospect has shown off some impressive tools in parts of five MLB seasons to become one of the best players on the Miami Marlins.
He’s bounced around the diamond, but the Phillies could use his glove in center field if they aren’t satisfied with the offense they’ve gotten from Johan Rojas.
It was a good idea in theory. However, Bob Nightengale poured cold water on the idea. It doesn’t look like Dombrowski has interest in pursuing this talented young player.
Photo by Megan Briggs/Getty Images
Tommy Pham
Tommy Pham made the Chicago White Sox his eighth MLB team in 11 seasons on April 16.
Pham hit 16 home runs and stole 22 bases with the New York Mets and the Arizona Diamondbacks in 2023. He finished the regular season with a .774 OPS, and he earned himself a spot in the lineup during Arizona’s run to the National League pennant.
The veteran righty hit .279 in 16 postseason games. His home run in Game 6 of the NLCS played a part in one of the most stunning two-day periods in Phillies history.
The White Sox won’t send Pham to become a key slugger for a World Series contender. However, he could be useful as a veteran journeyman looking for a playoff push late in his career.
Bob Nightengale pointed out on Philly Sports Tonight that the Phillies have passed on multiple opportunities to acquire Tommy Pham in recent seasons. They probably won’t change their outlook for an underwhelming addition at the 2024 MLB Trade Deadline.
Praising the current makeup of the Phillies clubhouse has become a point of emphasis internally and externally. They’re more likely to bring in a player who can help the lineup, not add a veteran presence that isn’t lacking on a first-place team.
FULL TRADE PROFILE: Tommy Pham
Taylor Ward
Dombrowski has built a reputation as one of the most aggressive MLB executives over decades of experience. Landing Taylor Ward wouldn’t be his biggest splash.
However, like the possibility of trading for Lane Thomas, Ward might make sense for the Phillies.
The 30-year-old left fielder has hit .368 against left-handed pitchers in the first half. He could provide the right-handed platoon option to supplement Marsh.
First glance at a .242/.326/.442 slash line won’t excite the Phillies fans looking for a Luis Robert Jr. deal. However, consider that his .763 OPS halfway through 2024 actually sits well above the plummeting MLB average.
Phillies Outfielders’ OPS Halfway Through 2024
- Brandon Marsh- .767
- Nick Castellanos- .662
- Johan Rojas- .566
- Cristian Pache- .565
- Whit Merrifield- .564
MLB teams can do worse than Taylor Ward in a platoon role, and the 2024 Phillies already have.
The Angels sat 12 games under .500 at the halfway point. They’re likely to sell at the MLB Trade Deadline.
Consider Ward in the same tier as Lane Thomas on the list of Dombrowski’s options.
Photo by John McCoy/Getty Images
