Are The Eagles Super Bowl Contenders In 2024?
The Eagles finally report to training camp on Tuesday. They will have their 3rd offensive coordinator in 3 years in Kellen more. They will have their 4th defensive coordinator in 3 years in Vic Fangio. They have added Saquon Barkley, and it appears that the Eagles’ added a lot of young talent on the defense in the draft. The ultimate question is, did Howie Roseman do enough to make the Eagles Super Bowl contenders again?
On the one hand, this offense should be elite. Outside of slot WR and maybe #2 tight end, there is high end talent all over the place. They have the best WR tandem in the NFL, a new star RB, an excellent offensive line, and Jalen Hurts poised for a bounce back year. While there will likely be growing pains early in the season, there is no reason to believe this won’t be a top 3 offense in the game.
Do The Eagles Have A Good Enough Defense To Win A Super Bowl?
The defense is where the questions really lie. Roseman did a poor job last year with the defense and then this offseason got rid of their best pass rusher in Reddick. He the went defense heavy in the draft this year with CB Quinyon Mitchell, CB Cooper DeJean, edge rusher Jalyx Hunt, and LB Jeremiah Trotter Jr.
While it seems likely that Mitchell and DeJean will contribute early, Hunt is a developmental project who may not even dress for games early. Trotter Jr seems destined to be a special team’s player to start his career with a chance to grow into more. New lead pass rusher Bryce Huff had 10 sacks last year in limited snaps, but will he be better in a larger role? Nolan Smith Jr had 1 sack last year and will be relied on heavily in year 2.
Jalen Carter has hall of fame talent. He could be that good. Is he ready to take that step and show more of it for 17 games? Jordan Davis is now clearly the main run stopper with Fletcher Cox gone, is he ready to play with more consistency? Who will the starting linebackers be? Will they really go with Zack Baun as their top guy? Is Reed Blankenship a full-time starter at safety? If the answer to most of these questions is yes, things will be great. If the answer is no, things could be very tough again.
So Are The Eagles Super Bowl Contenders?
When you add it all up, I think the Eagles should win the division. I think the Eagles will win a playoff game this season. I also think there are too many question marks to call them Super Bowl contenders. With another year to build up the defense, the Eagles could then bring us another parade.
Listen To Or Watch ‘The Best Show Ever?’ Live On The 97.5 The Fanatic And On NBC Sports Philly From 2 To 6 p.m. every Weekday
The All-Time Roster of Homegrown Philadelphia Eagles
Quarterback: Donovan McNabb
Randall Cunningham might have the most highlight-reel plays, but Donovan McNabb is the most accomplished quarterback in Eagles history. He was the centerpiece of the memorable period of sustained success and Super Bowl contention under Andy Reid in the early 2000s.
Athletes are not above criticism, and McNabb is far from an exception. However, it’s safe to say the Eagles nailed the second-overall pick in 1999, especially considering the underwhelming crop of quarterbacks in his draft class.
Running Back: Brian Westbrook
The Eagles executed one of the best drafts in their franchise history in 2002. They landed three quality defensive backs in the first two rounds, but their best selection came in the third round.
Brian Westbrook silenced the thought that he was only a third down back or a screen pass specialist. He developed into a feature back and the most consistent offensive weapon of the Andy Reid era.
It’s tough to find anyone in Philadelphia who doesn’t think highly of Westbrook. Wilbert Montgomery and LeSean McCoy deserve their accolades. However, they didn’t make the same contributions as number 36.
Fullback: Thomas Tapeh
The fullback might’ve faded from the modern NFL offense, but the position was a guarantee in past eras. The Eagles rotated a few notable free agent fullbacks like Leonard Weaver and Jon Ritchie, but they also drafted and developed Thomas Tapeh.
The fifth-rounder in 2004 spent three seasons with the Eagles and made 17 starts in 41 games.
Wide Receiver: Harold Carmichael
Hall of Fame wide receiver Harold Carmichael stood at 6-foot-7 with the ability to reach over helpless defensive backs. The Eagles landed an absolute steal in the seventh round of the 1971 NFL Draft.
He spent 13 seasons in Philadelphia and two games with the Dallas Cowboys. Carmichael famously retired because he couldn’t handle wearing a star on his helmet after so many years with the Eagles.
Wide Receiver: Mike Quick
The fight between Mike Quick and DeSean Jackson for the second wide receiver spot might’ve been the tightest on the list of homegrown Eagles.
Quick had more touchdowns. Jackson had more yards. Quick had more receptions. Jackson had more playoff games.
Five consecutive Pro Bowl appearances for Quick from 1983-1987 became the determining factor. DeSean Jackson had more memorable highlights, but he spent some of the best years of his career elsewhere and limited his own ceiling with cases of mismanaging his body.
Tight End: Zach Ertz
Pete Pihos certainly had a good enough career to land on the list of homegrown Eagles. However, Zach Ertz caught the game-winning touchdown in the franchise’s only Super Bowl. His fourth-down catch earlier in Super Bowl LII might have actually been a more impactful play too.
The Eagles drafted Ertz in the second round in 2013 after taking Lane Johnson in the first. He recovered from a questionable mistake in 2016 to earn the respect and admiration of Philadelphia fans forever.
Left Tackle: Tra Thomas
Tra Thomas anchored an offensive line that protected Donovan McNabb throughout one of the best eras in Eagles history. He made 165 starts in 11 seasons and earned three Pro Bowl nods.
He made it worthwhile for the Eagles to take the big left tackle out of Florida St. with the 11th-overall pick in 1998. He also did a heck of a job on 97.5 The Fanatic mornings after his playing career.
Left Guard: Todd Herremans
The Eagles spent a fourth-rounder in 2005 on a versatile offensive lineman from Saginaw Valley St. A lesser-known school didn’t stop Todd Herremans from making a name for himself.
He quickly pushed the Eagles to find a spot for him on their offensive line despite his lack of draft pedigree. He stuck around for excellent longevity with 124 starts over 10 seasons at multiple positions.
Center: Jason Kelce
Right Guard: Jermane Mayberry
Jon Runyan and Tra Thomas will always get most of the credit as the pillars of the offensive line in the early 2000s. However, Jermane Mayberry made plenty of contributions himself.
The Eagles spent the 26th-overall pick on a guard who gave them 112 games and 96 starts in nine seasons. Mayberry made his only career Pro Bowl in 2002.
Right Tackle: Lane Johnson
Three offensive tackles came off the board in the first four picks of the 2013 NFL Draft. The Eagles drafted Johnson behind Eric Fisher and Luke Joeckel but came away with exponentially more value.
Their incredible record with him in the lineup and mediocre record without him is no coincidence. Johnson is one of the toughest Eagles ever and arguably the best offensive lineman in franchise history.
Defensive Tackle: Fletcher Cox
Jason Kelce and Brandon Graham talked enough to control any spotlight. However, Fletcher Cox was the best player on the best team in franchise history.
The 2017 Eagles swallowed opponents who dared to try to run the ball. Fletcher Cox anchored the defensive front just like he did for most of his 12 NFL seasons, all spent in Midnight Green.
Cox made six Pro Bowls, and he’ll someday get his reward in Canton, Ohio.
Defensive Tackle: Jerome Brown
Reggie White and Jerome Brown might’ve formed the most fearsome pair of pass rushers in NFL history if tragedy didn’t cut Brown’s career short in 1992.
The Eagles drafted Brown with the ninth-overall pick in 1987. His raw talent helped him to two All-Pros in his final two seasons before his death at age 27.
The Gang Green defense still holds a special allure in the hearts of Eagles fans.
Defensive End: Brandon Graham
How do you choose between Trent Cole and Brandon Graham? Both edge rushers have landed toward the top of the franchise’s all-time sack leaders after prolonged careers in Philadelphia.
Cole edged the Super Bowl LII hero in sacks and earned two Pro Bowl selections. However, Graham was a heart and soul player for the Eagles in their only Super Bowl season and another appearance five years later.
Leaving either one of them off the list seemed unfair, but (former) noted draft bust Brandon Graham has one of the most admirable stories in Philadelphia sports history.
Left Outside Linebacker: Seth Joyner
Seth Joyner spent eight of his 13 NFL seasons in Philadelphia. He earned two of his three Pro Bowl nods in the early 1990s on the memorably feared defense under Bud Carson.
Only Brian Dawkins has ever forced more fumbles for the Eagles than Joyner. The former eighth-rounder (yes, there used to be more rounds) has the most sacks among linebackers in franchise history.
Middle Linebacker: Jeremiah Trotter
The Eagles regretted letting Jeremiah Trotter walk away when the 2002 and 2003 teams struggled with underwhelming linebacker play. They admitted it when they reunited with him in 2004.
Trotter developed into a star during his first four NFL seasons with the Eagles. He picked up where he left off with a Pro Bowl season in only nine starts for the NFC Champions in 2004.
The Axe Man never failed to fire up the Philadelphia crowd with his signature celebration.
Cornerback: Lito Sheppard
Troy Vincent and Bobby Taylor formed one of the NFL’s best cornerback duos of the early 2000s, but their time was running thin by 2002.
The Eagles drafted Lito Sheppard and Sheldon Brown to back up their previous duo. Both became valuable starters, but Sheppard separated himself with 18 interceptions and two Pro Bowl nods.
He famously picked off Drew Bledsoe and went the other way for 102 yards to seal the win against the Dallas Cowboys for revenge against Terrell Owens in his first game in Philadelphia with the arch-enemy.
Cornerback: Eric Allen
The Eagles selected Eric Allen with the 30th-overall pick in 1988. He became a key part of the feared Eagles defense of the late 1980s and early 1990s.
Allen’s name comes up annually as a notable Hall of Fame snub. However, he gets the honor of a starting job on the roster of homegrown Eagles.
Safety: Brian Dawkins
Philadelphia Eagles fans might never see another player with the stunning passion and heartfelt emotion of Brian Dawkins. Weapon X was one of the most feared hitters in the NFL. He earned nine Pro Bowl nods and four All-Pro selections that don’t even begin to describe his legacy.
His acceptance speech into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2018 revealed part of his life that drove his incredible passion.
Brian Dawkins is the most beloved Eagle in history. It’s safe to say he made a second-round pick in 1996 worthwhile.
