Rob Thomson Needs To Stop Sitting Bryson Stott Vs Lefites
Bryson Stott is having a breakout year. The 2nd year player has a slash line of .294/.331/.418/.749. He also has 13 steals to go with it. The counting numbers don’t jump off the page. But anyone who has watched him will tell you how impressive he has been. He almost always has a good at-bat. Even when he produces an out, it feels like he always at least made the pitcher work, or moved the runner over. So why is Stott not playing every day?
Yesterday’s game vs the Chicago Cubs marked the 4th time in June that Stott was not in the starting lineup. Why? Because Drew Smyly was on the mound. And Drew Smyly is a lefty. It was a trend for most of last year too. When the Phillies face lefties, Rob Thomson tends to sit Bryson Stott. Last year it was usually Edmundo Sosa replacing him at shortstop. But now that Stott is playing 2nd Base, it is Josh Harrison who fills in for him. The issue is Stott is hitting .321 vs lefties.
Thomson does the same thing with Brandon Marsh too, with Christian Pache playing Center when they play lefties. There it makes sense though. Marsh is hitting .217 vs lefties, and slugging under .400. But that is not the case with Stott. In fact, he hits lefties better than righties. Granted it is a smaller sample size.
A RUN!!!
— NBC Sports Philadelphia (@NBCSPhilly) June 17, 2023
Bryson Stott has two RBIs today, Phillies lead in the 11th pic.twitter.com/ivYZRgoVLO
I know Josh Harrison hit an HR last night. So at first glance, it feels like it paid off. But that is the exception to what has been the rule. This season his slash line is .233/.280/.326/.605. And it is even worse vs lefties. You are taking out one of your more dependable bats, and perhaps your best fielder, and replacing him with a guy who is struggling badly at the plate, and is not that great in the field anymore either.
I am fine with the Platoon in Centerfield. Marsh genuinely struggles vs lefties, and you have Christian Pache to fill in. At the very least, you know he will play great in center field. But that is not the case with Stott at 2nd. Not only are you taking out a productive bat vs lefties from the lineup, but you are also replacing him with someone who is a downgrade in every aspect of the game.
If it was just a one-time thing to get him a day off, fine. But he has sat vs 4 of 5 lefty starters this month. 4 times you took one of your better players so far this season out of the lineup. Enough. Bryson Stott has earned the right to play every day.
You may also enjoy:
Ranking The Phillies Biggest Needs At The Trade Deadline
1) Another Bat Who Can Play Everyday At Either First or in Left Field
This is kind of in limbo until we know if Bryce Harper is really a viable option at First base. If he can play first, then Kyle Schwarber can thankfully move to DH. That would open up Left Field to add another bat. But if Harper can’t make the switch in the middle of this season, then it would need to be First Base where they make the move.
Regardless, the lineup could use a boost. The name everyone loves to mention is Paul Goldschmidt. And if they could pull that off, it would be amazing. Even if that meant Harper had to keep DHing for now and Schwarber had to stay in Left. If you can add a bat like that, you do it. How realistic that move remains to be seen though. The Phillies should absolutely be in on him if the Cardinals try to move him. But it’s not something you can bank on happening.
(Photo by Greg Fiume/Getty Images)
The lineup needs more pop though. The Phillies are regularly playing guys who are not everyday players. Whether it be Edmundo Sosas, Kody Clemens, etc. Both have had moments where they looked good, but overall have not been productive enough. Which is what a bench bat does. They need someone who can be productive enough to play every day though for that 9th spot in the lineup. Some like the idea of playing Christian Pache in Left. And while that would be great for their defense, I have not seen enough from his bat to trust he can be an everyday guy yet. The best thing for Pache may be platooning in Center, and replacing Schwarber in Left late in games for defense.
The Leftfield options are not as pretty as the idea of trading for Paul Goldschmidt. Wil Myers is a free agent, but that is for a reason. Joc Pederson would be intriguing, but the Giants are playing well enough they may not be sellers. Jurickson Profar is barely productive at Coors Field. So if the Phillies look to go that way, they may need to get creative and acquire someone not being talked about much right now.
2) Bullpen Help
The Phillies have a very good backend of the bullpen. Jose Alvarado, Gregory Soto, and Craig Kimbrel have all been tremendous for them. Seranthony Dominguez is hurt, but after a slow start, he was pitching well too before he went on the IL.
It is when you go outside those 4 that you can get into trouble. Yunior Marte and Jeff Hoffman have been hard to trust of late. Both Connor Brogdon and Andrew Bellatii are currently in the minors after struggling at this level to start the season. Also, they may have broken Matt Strahm by using him too much early in the season as a starter.
They need more guys they can trust in the middle innings. Aroldis Chapman, who is having a bounce-back season, would have made sense, but he was traded to the Rangers. The White Sox could move Kendall Graveman for the right price. Joe Kelly is another name to watch. And of course, there are a lot of middle-tier relief pitchers we haven’t actually heard of that could be decent targets as well.
(Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)
They don’t need to make a splash here. But they definitely need some help when it comes to the middle of their bullpen. I also think they need to bring Brogdon and Bellatti back up because we know they have stuff that plays at this level, and they deserve another chance.
3) A 5th Starter
The hope is that this will be Andrew Painter. And if he can come up and live up to even half of the hype this season, that would fix the issue. But whatever the plan is, the Phillies need another starter. Christopher Sanchez has given them two decent starts in a row out of that 5th spot. And for now, he makes for a decent band-aid. But we have seen enough of him to know he is not a long-term solution. They will eventually need to have someone more reliable there.
Obviously, the first thing everyone thinks about is Shohei Ohtani. He would even kill two birds with one stone by giving them that extra bat too. That just seems unlikely. It would take a lot to get him and runs the risk that he leaves in the off-season, and you gave it all up for nothing.
If the Phillies add a starter, it will be a more realistic option. Like Eduardo Rodriguez. Rodriguez technically has a few years left on his deal. But he has an opt-out after this season. Given that he is having a career season, with a 2.13 ERA in 11 starts, he will likely exercise that option for a big payday this offseason. And that makes him pretty much a rental, and a prime trade candidate with the Tigers not likely to compete. Rodriguez has been a dependable MLB starter for years now. Even if there is a regression coming, his overall career numbers suggest he would be a good 5th starter for the Phillies.
(Photo by Ed Zurga/Getty Images)
Again, ideally, this gets filled by young of their young arms down in the minors. But the Phillies may want someone with more experience. And even if they do bring Painter up eventually, it could still serve them well to have another starter.
