It’s only March 13th as I type this, and regular season baseball is still over 2 weeks away for the Philadelphia Phillies, yet the starting rotation has already run into a couple of issues. Spring Training is a time to be cautious with the health of important players, especially when you had an extended postseason run like the Phillies did last year. Stack that on top of the offseason already being shorter due to last year’s lockout, and that can lead to a lot of extra stress on players’ bodies, especially pitchers. The Phils tuned up their rotation this offseason by adding Taijuan Walker in free agency, and the potential of having top pitching prospect in baseball Andrew Painter as the 5th starter looked like a real possibility when Spring Training starter… and then last week happened. It was not a good one for Phillies starters.
First, we got news that Andrew Painter was experiencing some discomfort in his throwing elbow, which threw some Phillies fans into a state of panic about their top prospect. It turns out, after a 2nd opinion from the best elbow surgeon in the country, that Painter in fact has a sprained UCL that should sideline him for over a month. That effectively ends the 19-year-old phenom’s chances of making the opening day roster, opening the door for Bailey Falter, but closing the door on one of the more interesting storylines of the spring. While it’s not a huge loss considering that Painter has never thrown a pitch at a level higher than AA, it’s a concerning first injury for a young player with a lot of expectations for the future.
Not only is Spring Training currently ongoing, but the World Baseball Classic has kicked off, with numerous Phillies competing. Ranger Suarez was scheduled to pitch for Venezuela in the tournament, but was recalled by the Phillies due to some tightness in his forearm on his throwing side. Now, according to Suarez’s comments since returning to Clearwater, the issue isn’t presumed to be serious. On the other hand, any arm tightness or discomfort for one of your starters, especially this early in the year, deserves a healthy amount of concern. It would be surprising to see Suarez miss anything close to as much time as Painter is scheduled to, but it may affect his ability to pitch early on in the season. I wouldn’t be super concerned about either pitcher long term, but these early issues could be a warning sign for how difficult it is to stay healthy this year with such a taxing season in 2022.
7 Phillies Named To MLB's Top 100 Players List
Rhys Hoskins (94)
Rhys is as hot and cold as players come. When he is hitting, he does it better than anyone. But the inconsistency, and the struggles in the field, keep him at 94. Which seems fair. The dumb errors can be maddening. But there is no run to the World Series without Rhys Hoskins. His bat is why they beat the Braves and the Padres. It is his last year before free agency, so he may be up for a career year.
(Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images)
Aaron Nola (79)
Aaron Nola has had his up and downs as a Phillie. A few years back he was a genuine Cy Young candidate. But he struggled to get back to that for a while. Until last year. He put together a great regular season and even broke the trend of September swoons. The ending was less than spectacular, with him struggling vs the Astros in the World Series. But Nola is a big reason they were there to begin with. And his great play was rewarded by cracking the Top 11, coming in at number 79.
(Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)
Kyle Schwarber (44)
When the Phillies signed Schwarber, fans knew they were getting a power bat. What they did not know was that he would provide as much of it as he went on to. He sent 52 balls into the outfield seats between the regular season and the postseason. Well, that is not technically true. Because I am pretty sure the one he hit in Game 1 vs the Padres never landed in the seats and is still in orbit. Schwarber is among the best power hitters in the sport. His below-average fielding, and low batting average, keep him out of the top 40.
But you will take those trade-offs when a guy does what Schwarber can with a bat. And while the batting average is low, he walks a ton to make up for it. He jumped from 80 last year up to 44.
(Photo by Bob Levey/Getty Images)
Zack Wheeler (35)
Wheeler is about as good as they come. They asked a lot of him last season, and he delivered. There was a tiny hiccup vs the Astros. But for the most part, he pitched like a Cy Young last year. And he could have been if there weren’t pitchers like Sandy Alcantara doing inhuman things. They may go a bit easier on Wheeler this year, just so there is less fatigue in the playoffs. But we know for a fact that Wheeler will be as good as any pitcher when it matters most. He came in at 35 this year, after being ranked 25 in 2022.
(Photo by Rich Schultz/Getty Images)
JT Realmuto (29)
It looked a little bit dicey early in the season. But by the end of the year, JT Realmuto once against confirmed he is the best catcher in baseball. In the second half, there are few players who hit better than him period. He had the 5th best OPS after the All-Star Break in the entire MLB. And behind the plate, no one prevents steals better than him. His efforts helped him jump from 54 last year up to 29 for this season.
(Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images)
Bryce Harper (17)
Harper will, unfortunately, miss the first couple of months as he recovers from Tommy Johns. But when he is healthy, there may not be 5 better players in the league than him, let alone 16. That was on full display in the playoffs where he at times carried the Phillies lineup, including one of the most clutch home runs in Phillies history in game 5 vs the Padres. Landing at 17 makes sense if you factor in the injury and that he may not be able to play the field until late in the season. But Harper should be much higher if going just by talent. He fell from 5 to 17.
(Photo by Tim Nwachukwu/Getty Images)
Trea Turner (11)
And one of the newest Phillies is also the one who ranks highest on this list. Turner is the best Shortstop in Baseball. He is also probably the fastest man in Baseball. His speed at the top of the lineup could make a huge difference for the Phillies this year. And his range at shortstop could be key with the league banning the shift. He makes consistent contact, plays great in the field, provides some pop, and will steal you a ton of bases. Trea Turner could quickly become one of our favorite all-time Phillies. He comes in at 11, after being ranked 13 last year with the Dodgers.
(Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images)