Question of The Day- Are the Phillies Allowed a Champagne Celebration?

Every day on "The Best Show Ever?" we ask the question of the day. For instance, on Friday we asked should Tua Tagovailoa have been allowed to play last night. And you can see the answers we go to that here. But today, our question was about the Phillies, and how they should handle themselves if they do clinch the playoffs in these next few days. So if tonight the Phillies lose, but still make the playoffs because the Brewers also lose, should they do the full celebration with champagne?

The Phillies season started in a really bad way. But after Joe Girardi was fired, things turned around. And now the Phillies might make the playoffs. But an ugly month of September has soured the prospect of breaking the decade-long playoff drought. The concept of a Red October doesn't bring the same hype it would have a month ago. But even though they are backing into the playoffs, and may make it because of another team's loss as opposed to their win, should there be a player celebration?

Hunter Brody said of course not. He said it would be loser mentality to celebrate like that after a loss. He doesn't need them to be upset, but they can't act like they won a playoff series. Ricky Bo said it wouldn't bother him. He knows it was going to happen anyway. But he did suggest to go with beer instead of champagne to it is not as formal. Jen liked the idea of beer instead of champagne. Tyrone said no champagne. But then he added a second question. He asked which players should be excluded from the celebration if they win..

Hunter said Nick Castellanos. Ricky Bo said Kyle Gibson. Jen said that Bryce Harper. And Tyrone Nick Nelson. They also said JT Realmuto has to show up to the celebration late the way he showed up to play in this season late. And Rhys is allowed to be in and out of the party they way he only played well this season for short stretches.